TICKERNERD
Menu
SIGISIGIFinancial Services · Insurance - Property & Casualty

SIGI Stock Forecast: Selective Insurance Group, Inc. Price Predictions for 2026-2027

Last close, 24 Sept 2026
$86
−0.65% on the day

The 8 Wall Street analysts covering Selective Insurance Group, Inc. hold a median 12-month price target of $105 — +22.4% from the last close. Ticker Nerd's systematic factor model, run across ~4,600 US stocks, ranks it 61 of 100 as at 23 Sept 2026 — in the upper half.

Market cap
$5.1B
Ticker Nerd rank
61 / 100
Median analyst target
$105
Analysts covering
8
Revenue$1.4B+4.5% y/y
Net income$129.4M
Free cash flow$214.9M
Quarterly, 8 quarters to 30 June 2026 · latest quarter's figure shown
Total return, dividends reinvested
1W
−1.6%
1M
−7.4%
YTD
+4.0%
1Y
+11.0%
From 52W high
−14.0%
From 52W low
+18.2%
$73
$100
52-week range, adjusted closes · the dot is the last close
Ticker Nerd rank

SIGI stock analysis: one number for the whole business

Consensus tells you what everyone already believes. The model scores Selective Insurance Group, Inc. on its factor families — the same systematic rank behind the Ticker Nerd portfolio.

Where the model ranks itAs at 23 Sept 2026
61 / 100

Percentile across ~4,600 US stocks on Ticker Nerd’s systematic factor model. Higher is better. How the model is built and tested

Issuance
80
Growth
77
Momentum
72
Volatility
69
Value
62
Quality
58
Revisions
52
Accruals
23
Size
22

Issuance (80): The share count has been shrinking and the company is not leaning on new borrowing.

Accruals (23): A large share of reported profit has not shown up as cash, or the balance sheet is expanding quickly — both tend to unwind.

Size (22): Larger than most of the companies we track — more scrutinised, less often mispriced.

Built and run by Aslam Ghouse, an ex-Goldman Sachs quant trader with fourteen years in markets.

Wall Street

SIGI stock forecast 2026-2027: analyst price targets & predictions

The bullish and bearish analyst opinions on SIGI, reported as data — targets and ratings, the market's view beside the model's.

Share price and the analyst range, 12 monthsAdjusted close, US dollars
$70$80$90$100$110$120Oct 25Jan 26Apr 26Jul 26SIGIHigh $115Median $105Low $80

Price targets and ratings are third-party analyst estimates, reported here as data. They are not Ticker Nerd forecasts, and they are frequently wrong.

Data provided by Twelve Data

What Wall Street says8 analysts
2 Buy5 Hold1 Sell
Low $80Median $105High $115

The green dot is the last close — the median target sits +22.4% from it.

Recent analyst actionsNewest first

Of the 20 most recent actions, 6 moved their price target up and 0 moved it down.

DateFirmActionRatingTarget
30 July 2026Keefe, Bruyette & WoodsMaintainsMarket Perform$101 → $102
28 July 2026BMO CapitalDowngradeMarket Perform$97
27 July 2026RBC CapitalMaintainsOutperform$110 → $115
15 July 2026Piper SandlerMaintainsNeutral$93 → $103
15 July 2026Piper SandlerMaintainsNeutral—
13 July 2026RBC CapitalMaintainsOutperform$100 → $110
13 July 2026RBC CapitalMaintainsOutperform—
8 July 2026Keefe, Bruyette & WoodsMaintainsMarket Perform$88 → $101
8 July 2026Keefe, Bruyette & WoodsMaintainsMarket Perform—
6 July 2026Morgan StanleyMaintainsUnderweight$72 → $80
6 July 2026Morgan StanleyMaintainsUnderweight—
26 May 2026Piper SandlerMaintainsNeutral—
21 May 2026OppenheimerMaintainsOutperform—
7 May 2026BMO CapitalUpgradeOutperform—
24 Apr 2026Keefe, Bruyette & WoodsMaintainsMarket Perform—
7 Apr 2026Keefe, Bruyette & WoodsMaintainsMarket Perform—
23 Mar 2026RBC CapitalReiteratesOutperform—
2 Feb 2026Piper SandlerMaintainsNeutral—
6 Jan 2026Keefe, Bruyette & WoodsMaintainsMarket Perform—
22 Dec 2025Piper SandlerMaintainsNeutral—

Price targets and ratings are third-party analyst estimates, reported here as data. They are not Ticker Nerd forecasts, and they are frequently wrong.

Market Radar

This page is one stock. Monday covers all of them.

Computed off the Friday close and sent before the US open.

Market Radar reports the week’s largest rank changes across roughly 4,600 US stocks, the factor behind each one, and where the market went. SIGI appears on the weeks it earns a place.

Free, every Monday. Unsubscribe any time.

Performance

SIGI vs the S&P 500

Both lines are total return — dividends reinvested — so the comparison is honest on both sides.

Over the twelve months to 24 Sept 2026, Selective Insurance Group, Inc. returned +11.0% against +17.3% for the S&P 500, dividends included.

SIGI vs S&P 500, last 12 monthsTotal return, rebased to 100
90100110120130Oct 25Jan 26Apr 26Jul 26SIGIS&P 500

Download this chart as an image — free to reuse; link this page as the source.

Data provided by Twelve Data

Estimates

SIGI analyst estimate revisions

Not the forecast itself — the direction analysts are revising it. Revision direction is one of the model's factor families.

Which way the estimates are movingNext fiscal year
EPS revision, 90 days
+3.8%
Analysts raising
6
Analysts cutting
2
Fundamentals

Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI) financial data

A margin means little on its own. Each bar marks where the figure sits across the whole US universe we score.

Valuation
Trailing P/E
10.6×

Cheaper than 56% of US stocks

Price / sales
0.9×

Cheaper than 70% of US stocks

Price / book
1.5×

Cheaper than 54% of US stocks

EV / EBITDA
8.1×

Cheaper than 44% of US stocks

Growth & margins
Revenue growth (YoY)
4.5%

Higher than 37% of US stocks

Earnings growth (YoY)
50.5%

Higher than 75% of US stocks

Gross margin
—
Operating margin
12.7%

Higher than 69% of US stocks

Net margin
9.1%

Higher than 68% of US stocks

Returns & dividend
Return on equity
14.2%

Higher than 72% of US stocks

Return on assets
2.8%

Higher than 64% of US stocks

Dividend yield
2.0%

Higher than 43% of US dividend payers

Bars mark the percentile across the ~4,600 US stocks Ticker Nerd covers, among those reporting the figure.

Key statistics

Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI) statistics: revenue, profit & scale

The headline figures, each with its date. Every row carries its own link — cite it straight from here.

  • Selective Insurance Group, Inc. has a market value of $5.1B and an enterprise value of $5.8B.

  • Revenue in the twelve months to 30 June 2026: $5.5B. The latest quarter grew 4.5% year on year.

  • Net income over the same four quarters: $497.6M, a 9.1% net margin.

  • Diluted earnings per share, trailing twelve months: $8.06.

  • Free cash flow in the twelve months to 30 June 2026: $1.2B, after $43.5M of capital spending.

  • Selective Insurance Group, Inc. spent $134.5M on share buybacks and $106.8M on dividends in the twelve months to 30 June 2026.

  • Shares outstanding: 59.6M.

  • Trailing P/E: 10.6×; forward P/E: 9.8× — the forward figure prices analyst consensus estimates, not reported earnings.

  • Forward dividend yield: 2.01%, paying out 21% of earnings.

  • Selective Insurance Group, Inc. employs 2,800 people — $2.0M of revenue per employee.

Statement figures: company filings via Twelve Data, four quarters to 30 June 2026 · market figures as at 25 Sept 2026

Data provided by Twelve Data

Peers

SIGI vs competitors

The nearest names by industry and size, scored by the same model — like for like.

Its peer group, ranked by the same modelInsurance - Property & Casualty
CompanyMarket capTKN rank
SIGISelective Insurance Group, Inc.$5.1B
61
RLIRLI Corp.$5.2B
61
MCYMercury General Corp.$5.4B
75
WTMWhite Mountains Insurance Group Ltd.$4.8B
72
HGTYHagerty, Inc.$4.7B
35
THGThe Hanover Insurance Group, Inc.$7.6B
87
KNSLKinsale Capital Group, Inc.$7.7B
49

Look up any of the roughly 4,600 stocks we score.

The rank is the raw material. Whether the rules would actually own Selective Insurance Group, Inc. — and when they’d sell — is the membership. See the Ticker Nerd 20 →

News

Latest SIGI news & analysis

3 P&C Insurers Stand to Gain From Higher Fixed-Income Yields

Zacks Investment Research · 22 Sept 2026positive

Zacks Investment Research reports that the Federal Reserve's rate hike to 3.75-4% can boost investment income for property and casualty insurers including Selective Insurance Group. As their bonds mature and are reinvested at higher yields, insurers like TRV, SIGI, and RLI stand to gain from the increased fixed-income environment.

Why it matters — A SIGI watcher would care because higher reinvestment yields on maturing bonds could strengthen the company's investment income, a key driver of overall earnings.

SIGI's Investment Income Boosts Earnings Despite Underwriting Pressure

Zacks Investment Research · 17 Sept 2026positive

Selective Insurance's investment income remains a significant earnings driver, with higher yields and growth in invested assets supporting results even as underwriting tailwinds moderate.

Why it matters — A SIGI watcher would care because investment income is providing a key offset to softening underwriting conditions, helping sustain earnings performance.

Selective Appoints Wole Coaxum as Independent Director

Business Wire · 16 Sept 2026neutral

Selective Insurance Group announced that Wole Coaxum has been appointed to its Board of Directors, effective immediately. Coaxum previously served as an independent director for Selective from 2020 to 2025, and the Board now comprises 13 directors, 12 of whom are independent.

Why it matters — For Selective watchers, this appointment adds an experienced returning director to the Board, which Chairman John J. Marchioni said enhances the collective Board capabilities.

Here's Why Selective Insurance (SIGI) is a Strong Growth Stock

Zacks Investment Research · 15 Sept 2026positive

Zacks Investment Research highlighted Selective Insurance (SIGI) as a strong growth stock, using its Zacks Style Scores feature from the Zacks Premium research service to identify it. The article notes that the Style Scores tool helps value, growth, and momentum investors find strong stocks.

Why it matters — A positive Zacks style-score assessment signals that SIGI is being recognized as a strong growth pick, which a shareholder or prospective investor would care about.

Here's Why Selective Insurance (SIGI) is a Strong Growth Stock

Zacks Investment Research · 21 Aug 2026positive

Zacks Investment Research highlighted Selective Insurance (SIGI) as a strong growth stock, based on its Style Scores system designed to help investors identify top-rated stocks by investing style. The piece introduces the Zacks Style Scores ranking approach and points to SIGI as one of the qualifying stocks.

Why it matters — A SIGI watcher would care because the Zacks Style Scores designation indicates Selective Insurance is being flagged favorably by a widely used stock-ranking methodology, which may boost its visibility among investors.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions about SIGI stock

What is the SIGI stock price forecast for 2026-2027?

The 8 Wall Street analysts covering Selective Insurance Group, Inc. have a median 12-month price target of $105, with estimates ranging from $80 to $115. These are third-party analyst estimates, not Ticker Nerd forecasts, and they are frequently wrong.

Is SIGI stock a buy right now?

Of the 8 analysts covering Selective Insurance Group, Inc., 2 rate it a Buy, 5 a Hold and 1 a Sell. Ticker Nerd's systematic factor model ranks Selective Insurance Group, Inc. 61 out of 100 across roughly 4,600 US stocks as at 23 Sept 2026. None of this is personal advice — it does not consider your circumstances.

How does Ticker Nerd's model rank SIGI?

As at 23 Sept 2026, Selective Insurance Group, Inc. ranks 61 out of 100 on Ticker Nerd's systematic factor model — a percentile across roughly 4,600 US stocks, built from its factor families. Its strongest factor family is Issuance (80 of 100).

Will SIGI stock go up?

No one can know that. What the data says: the median 12-month target from 8 analysts implies +22.4% from the last close, and Ticker Nerd's factor model ranks Selective Insurance Group, Inc. 61 out of 100 as at 23 Sept 2026. Analyst targets are third-party estimates and frequently wrong; none of this is personal advice.

What is the SIGI stock forecast for 2030?

No analyst covering Selective Insurance Group, Inc. publishes a 2030 price target — Wall Street targets run 12 to 18 months out. Sites quoting a 2030 price for SIGI are extrapolating price history, which says nothing about the business. The furthest attributed numbers are the current analyst targets: $80 to $115 over the next 12 months.

How has SIGI stock performed over the past year?

Selective Insurance Group, Inc. returned +11.0% over the 12 months to 24 Sept 2026, with dividends reinvested. Past performance does not indicate future returns.

What does Selective Insurance Group, Inc. do?

Selective Insurance Group, Inc. is a property and casualty insurance holding company that provides insurance products and services in the United States.

What is the latest news on SIGI?

The most recent item we track (Zacks Investment Research, 22 Sept 2026): "3 P&C Insurers Stand to Gain From Higher Fixed-Income Yields". Zacks Investment Research reports that the Federal Reserve's rate hike to 3.75-4% can boost investment income for property and casualty insurers including Selective Insurance Group. As their bonds mature and are reinvested at higher yields, insurers like TRV, SIGI, and RLI stand to gain from the increased fixed-income environment.

Company

About Selective Insurance Group, Inc.

Selective Insurance Group, Inc. is a property and casualty insurance holding company that provides insurance products and services in the United States. The company focuses on commercial, personal, and excess and surplus lines through four operating segments: Standard Commercial Lines, Standard Personal Lines, E&S Lines, and Investments. Its commercial offerings serve businesses, nonprofit organizations, and local government agencies with coverage such as workers’ compensation, general liability, property, and commercial auto insurance. The personal lines business provides auto, homeowners, and flood insurance, while the E&S segment addresses clients who need coverage outside the standard insurance market. Selective Insurance Group, Inc. also manages investment activities tied to its insurance operations, supporting the broader financial foundation of its business.

CEO Mr. John Joseph Marchioni CPCU · 2,800 employees · United States · https://www.selective.com